Your Vision, Our Expertise.

Your trusted partner in Health, Dental, Vision, life, Individual, Small and Large Group Business, Medicare, Marketplace and Life Insurance Products!

Our Story

We started with a simple idea: build something extraordinary. We are a family owned small business and from the ground up, we've focused on creating insurance packages that actually work for our clients! Forging lasting relationships with our clients, is absolutely our most important task as a company. Today, we're a team driven by a passion for what we do, turning your vision into reality, one customized insurance product at a time!

Board of Directors

Optimal Choice Insurance's image

Melissa Petrillo

Owner/Broker

Optimal Choice Insurance's image

Mike Petrillo

Owner

Safety

We create a secure environment where everyone prioritizes the importance of protecting your privacy and personal information.

Quality

We build meticulous packages and follow up with quick and reliable customer service.

Teamwork

We earn trust through honesty and ethical conduct in every interaction.

Sustainability

We try to minimize our carbon footprint and utilize digital documents whenever possible to cut down on paper use!

Vision

Mission

Building a Legacy of Excellence: We strive to be a leader in the Insurance industry, renowned for exceptional quality and innovation.

Our Mission is to educate our clients in the ever changing realm that is Health Insurance! By accomplishing this we assist you in making the Best choices for you, your families and your business!

Let's Build Something Great Together.